Royal Commission Says Home Insulation Program Was Poorly Planned And Poorly Implemented

The report of the Royal Commission into the Home Insulation Program (HIP) says the scheme was poorly planned and poorly implemented.

The report by Ian Hanger, released today, says the causes of the problems were “multifactorial” and “it is not possible to isolate one error or failure”.

HIP

The report concludes that there were “seven significant failings in the design and implementation of HIP”. These included:

  • Conflict or tension between the two aims of the program to insulate 2.2 million homes and to stimulate the economy.
  • The Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts was ill-equipped to deal with the size and complexity of the HIP.
  • A failure by the Australian Government, until very late in the HIP, to identify and manage the risk to installers of injury and death.
  • Permitting a produce to be used under the HIP that was manifestly unsuitable and dangerous.
  • A decision to relax training and competency requirements for insulation training.
  • A robust audit and compliance regime was not operational until after the first fatality.
  • The Australian Government’s reliance on the States, Territories and employers to regulate, monitor, police and enforce occupational health and safety arrangements.

The report says the Home Insulation Program not only had an effect on the families of the young men killed: “It also wreaked havoc on pre-existing insulation installation businesses, particularly when the HIP was suspended on 19 February 2010, essentially without warning.” [Read more…]


Kevin Rudd Appears At Home Insulation Royal Commission: Argument Over Cabinet Secrecy

The former Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, has appeared at the Royal Commission into his government’s home insulation scheme.

Rudd took the stand just after 5pm. The Commission adjourned at about 6.15pm without any substantive testimony from Rudd.

Instead, the Royal Commissioner, Ian Hanger QC, and lawyers debated whether Cabinet confidentiality applied to Rudd’s testimony. A heavily redacted version of a 31-page statement by Rudd was tendered to the hearing. Cabinet documents relevant to the inquiry have been released by the Cabinet Office with limits on their use. In the normal course of events, Cabinet documents remain secret for at least 20 years. [Read more…]